Neil Gaiman    www.NeilgaimanBoard.com    www.NeilgaimanBoard.com  Hop To Forum Categories  The World's End  Hop To Forums  FLAME WARS    Is Panda a horrible racist?
Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
is in perfect karmic alignment
Member
Picture of Pumpkifins
Posted Hide Post
The personal comments aside (which i couldn't know less about) a big amen to that, and i shall now bump the "Hot Guys" thread....


~You are a *Taverner*.
Sometimes patrons want to go where everybody knows their names, though it helps 
when half of them are named John. When people want to celebrate, or commiserate, 
they gather to your establishment. You provide the atmosphere, the warmth, rum, 
and even an ear to bend. Did I mention the rum? Years before the language will be 
mangled with terms like facilitator and networking and interpersonal communication,
you've overseen it all, and broken up a few bar fights, to boot.~
-Royko
 
Posts: 6721 | Location: Just north of Earth | Registered: July 02, 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by The First of the Fallen:
[...]

Nope, sorry, don't buy it. I agree with you, but that's not what you've been saying in the past. Unless I completely misunderstood your earlier posts, Fallen, you've always argued that in a system that advocates free speech, you don't have to censor hate speech because people are free to counter it. You are free to speak against what people are doing in this thread, and you're doing so, but your call to have it closed is hypocritical. I'm sorry, but I can't see it any other way.

And I definitely find it hypocritical to talk about the right to express an idea with respect to racism and anti-semitism (not what you said explicitly, but that's how it comes across in your direct reply to what I say) and then to say that this is somehow better than the direct abuse of a particular person. "Niggers and Kikes don't deserve to live!!! But of course I don't mean any particular person." How's that any better or more acceptable than "You there, Frank Bloggs, you're a jerk and a racist and I hate you!"? Why should the former be protected under free speech and the latter be censored?

You talk about standing up for the underdog, yet you're naive if you think that free speech always favours the underdog.


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
will not Ling Ling you, not ever
Member
Picture of Big Ass Panda
Posted Hide Post
I'm glad Dweller posted what he did in saying he's not going to remove the thread, because I don't want to see it removed.

I personally see this thread as an ugly spot on the board, regardless of who it was aimed at. It is good to be reminded of our mistakes and our idiocies.

Furthermore, going onto the anti-racism laws, I entirely support legislature defending indivisuals/small comunities against crimes, however I am very much against sensoring someone based on the fact that you disagree with what they say! Bring those Nazies to the front and let them express their views so it can be seen for the idiocy it is.


*********************
And I'm better built to boot!
~Ranma
 
Posts: 3803 | Location: Basking in the desert sun at the cliff's edge | Registered: February 08, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Member
Posted Hide Post
Sing it bro!

And all you monkey humping sons of apes can back the f*ck up right now before I drop some bamboo-chewing science on your unlovable assholes.
 
Posts: 12 | Location: Gameplayer- I like to play. When I'm alone I play... with myself. | Registered: October 30, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Big Ass Panda:
Furthermore, going onto the anti-racism laws, I entirely support legislature defending indivisuals/small comunities against crimes, however I am very much against sensoring someone based on the fact that you disagree with what they say! Bring those Nazies to the front and let them express their views so it can be seen for the idiocy it is.

Yeah, because that so worked with Germany in the 1930s... Roll Eyes (Whatever your take is on freedom of speech, your attitude is naive as hell. As if the truth always won out in society...)


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
will not Ling Ling you, not ever
Member
Picture of Big Ass Panda
Posted Hide Post
Heh, I am a bit naive, but I really do think that Germany in the 1930's is a completly different situation. Other than changing the economic situation, I really don't know if there is anything that could have stopped what happened then (After it reached the critical point). Maybe a different ideology to divert their momentum?

Anyhow, I still stand that people will listen to reason as long as the situation is handled right and they are exposed to reason.

But then again, I am naive Big Grin


*********************
And I'm better built to boot!
~Ranma
 
Posts: 3803 | Location: Basking in the desert sun at the cliff's edge | Registered: February 08, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Did something right
Member
Picture of Tongster
Posted Hide Post
*Shrug* I chose the title based on a post by Panda where he used the phrase "horrible racist". I just pulled the description from his post.

EDIT: Copied post here:
quote:
Originally posted by Big Ass Panda:
Of course, I'm not doing that at all. I believe that certain races are naturally superior to other races. It's rather clear, as you all have seen.

As far as discussion goes, I don't know, maybe something about personality steriotypes etc.

After looking at what I could find online:
quote:
Inheriting Stereotypes
The other area where Asian parents cause their sons no amount of grief is not really their fault. Actually, it's the stereotypes that the former generations cause the latter generations to inherit. Let me explain.

One common criticism to the points we make on this site is something along the lines of: "Of COURSE girls don't want Asian men! Asian men are sexist pigs who expect their wives to stay in the kitchen, not speak unless being spoken to, walk five paces behind their husband, and bear as many children as necessary until they give their husband a son!" This is where the stereotypes come in. While it's true that maybe two generations ago, such views were valid, things are not the same today. And yet the view still holds. It's so bad such that Asian girls born in America, having seen how their father treats their mother or how their grandfather treats their grandmother, swears she'll never date an Asian man, because she mistakenly assumes that all the Asian men her age will treat her like that. This assumption is fallacious as any Asian man born in America will likewise have seen how his grandfather has treated his grandmother and sworn never to do the same. Yet this will never help him because Asian girls will run away from him in needless fear.

White girls, too, while not having witnessed such Asian sexism firsthand, usually will have heard generalized accounts on how subservient Asian women are, and will have heard statements of varying validity, ranging from the fairly sad but true such as "Asian husbands will put their work before you" to the completely invalid in the modern day like "Asian husbands will make you bind your feet". The end result is the same. The modern girl who has her eyes on career and a semi-independent life will be told "Don't marry an Asian - you'll never see anything but the inside of a kitchen for the rest of your life".

This inheritance of stereotypes is insidious in large part because the Asian male can do nothing about it. He can treat all the girls he knows in as gentlemanly a manner as possible (a move likely to put him on the Friends Ladder - see the Ladder Theory in our Links for more), and still the average girl will be told, by the stereotype "Oh sure, he treats you nicely now. Just wait until you have to cook his food and bear his sons." That's not to say that no Asian men today are like that - there are still some that are. It's just that we're all painted with the same negative brush that's really frustrating. This stereotype is like saying that all Southerners must be racist, since not even fifty years ago blacks had to sit in the back of the bus and use separate water fountains - while calling Southerners racist, like calling Asian men sexist, might still be true for some members of the population, it by no means holds true for everybody.


Obviously other people have thought about this matter in general. This passage may or may not be accurate or not in some cases (I really have no experience) but it is something that's there.

The existance of racism in general is interesting. I find much of the recent racism in the US about Hispanic people has many similarities to the prejudices experienced by Irish and Polish imigrants earlier on.

But clearly I'm a horrible racist so pay no attention to me.


----------------------------------------------------------
"It really is fun to to stick burning objects into various orifices."
"Sorry I haven't been around much, but I am easily distracted by shiny objects."
"WEIRD! WEIRDY-WEIRDO-WEIRD! WEIRDOPOTTAMUS WEIRDOSAUR! HIM! YOU! WEIRD!"-Mr. Furious
 
Posts: 11331 | Registered: February 18, 2003Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Big Ass Panda:
Anyhow, I still stand that people will listen to reason as long as the situation is handled right and they are exposed to reason.

And that - "as long as the situation is right" - is as vague as hell. I don't know about your neck of the woods, but here young people become neo-Nazis because

a) they might come from less well educated, economically disadvantaged families, or

b) they're rebelling against what their parents/teachers tell them, or

c) because they think it's cool to hate and beat up people, or

d) any other reason.

They've all got access to the truth about what Nazis did in Germany 1933-1945. They don't care. Listening to reason? They're more likely to kick it half to death and then piss on it.

I can definitely accept it if someone says that absolute freedom of speech might not be ideal, but it's the best we can offer ('thin end of the wedge' sort of argument). But bullshit about 'truth will out' simply doesn't work if you look at world history. People act out of want or need, and they rarely want or need truth and reason, it seems.


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
will not Ling Ling you, not ever
Member
Picture of Big Ass Panda
Posted Hide Post
It is probably the most tasteless thing I've ever seen on this board. It definitely is an ugly spot on here for a group who prides themselves on intelligent discussion.

It shows a lack of thinking on your part. I know you're not a bad guy, but you definitely screwed up hard core on this one.

But like I said before, I absolve you of your wrong doings because of your weakness.

Edit'ed to respond to Thirith:

I don't know. When I say "situation is right" I should have said, as long as the situation is confronted.

While I'll agree with the statement that, "absolute freedom of speech might not be ideal, but it's the best we can offer" I would even perhaps go a step further and say that it's the better of two roads. If you silence someone, it only validates their view and they gain strength.

Will the truth win out? Only if it confonts the lies.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Big Ass Panda,


*********************
And I'm better built to boot!
~Ranma
 
Posts: 3803 | Location: Basking in the desert sun at the cliff's edge | Registered: February 08, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
You're welcome.


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Member
Posted Hide Post
ooh ooh absolve me too!
 
Posts: 12 | Location: Gameplayer- I like to play. When I'm alone I play... with myself. | Registered: October 30, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Administrator/Colporteur
Member
Picture of Dweller in Darrkness
Posted Hide Post
I think a line needs to be drawn between hate speech and racist speech. Both are wrong, and for similar reasons, but the latter if harmful in ways well beyond the emotional, the latter is just . . . wrong.

If I say, "I don't trust Jews," that's a racist statement, and a wrong-headed one, even if it's based on my own experiences. It isn't, in and of itself, damaging.

If I say, "I don't trust Jews and I think they shouldn't be able to own business," that's a whole different level of wrong that leads to Kristallnacht.

I want people to be able to say the former quite freely so that such statements can be caught and hopefully corrected. While I agree that there's a spectrum that leads a person to first say the first statement and gradually come to agree with the statement, unless we've heard them say the first, there's no chance for rehabilitation. The latter . . . that you have to watch out for.


__________
AJGraeme
"You see, I have a policy about honesty and ass-kicking: if you ask for it, I have to let you have it."
-Taylor Mali
"Science is the foot that kicks magic square in the nuts."
-Scratch Fury
 
Posts: 43003 | Location: Concord, NH, USA | Registered: July 20, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
Absolutely, Dweller. No one here will be tried, or even charged, if they say "I don't trust Jews." The thing that's important to me is that a black and white view of the issue (i.e. "Any curtailing of free speech is wrong! People should be free to say anything!") isn't really adequate to this complicated, ambivalent, wonderful, fucked up world we live in. Which is why I usually get so frustrated discussing things with ideologues and their principles which are so unflexible that they have little to nothing to do with the real world.


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
has a beaver that talks
Member
Picture of supersnazz: fiend for rawk!
Posted Hide Post
quote:
but the latter if harmful in ways well beyond the emotional, the latter is just . . . wrong.


For which one of those two did you mean "the former"?


******************************************
Me in Rock: This Shirt Is Pants | Mr. Fusion
Me in blog: izenmania
 
Posts: 14683 | Location: A few miles west of crazy... | Registered: August 01, 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
has no member title
Member
Picture of His Noodle Girl
Posted Hide Post
Jesus Christ! Panda, what kind of dream land do you live in??
Thirith is a hundred percent correct in his analysis of neonazis and their and the perfect uselessness of exposing them to "reason".

What on earth is tasteless about that?

It's kind of funny that first of all you were accusing people of not looking reality in the face and then you say completely naive bullshit like "people will listen to reason as long as the situation is handled right and they are exposed to reason."

That's not only naive to the extreme it is also dangerous in that it enables the very stupidity to grow that you would want to prevent. History has proved you wrong a hundredfold, Panda! Open your bushy little ears and listen!

WTF is so tasteless about what Thirith said? If you mean dragging the Nazis into that, that was your doing, not his.


__
The brickchewing, camera flaunting restroom saint formerly known as Babylon the Bride
 
Posts: 12221 | Location: Bouncing round in bathrooms! | Registered: October 19, 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Goofy Beast
Member
Picture of Thirith & His Enormous Tibia
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Babylon the Bride:
WTF is so tasteless about what Thirith said? If you mean dragging the Nazis into that, that was your doing, not his.

He was responding to Tongster, I think. My "You're welcome" was sarcasm, but it didn't exactly make things clearer. Smile


__________
We scraped along like rats, but now we will soar like eagles… eagles on pogo sticks!
 
Posts: 9704 | Location: Switzerland | Registered: September 05, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
has no member title
Member
Picture of His Noodle Girl
Posted Hide Post
Rofl!
You guys! As if all the aliases sleazing about the board weren't bad enough.

Sorry Panda, I was totally flummoxed by your strange reaction to what I thought was Thirith's post.

Sorry if I reacted harshly. Smile


__
The brickchewing, camera flaunting restroom saint formerly known as Babylon the Bride
 
Posts: 12221 | Location: Bouncing round in bathrooms! | Registered: October 19, 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Administrator/Colporteur
Member
Picture of Dweller in Darrkness
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Babylon the Bride:
Thirith is a hundred percent correct in his analysis of neonazis and their and the perfect uselessness of exposing them to "reason".

I disagree here. Most of the time, bigots are "reasoned" with by being yelled at about how utterly and completely incorrect their opinion is while pages of documentation are shoved into their face. The first step - the first reasonable step - to excommunicating a neo-Nazi, or any other bigot, is to attack the root problem, whether poverty or feelings disenfranchisement or indoctrination.


__________
AJGraeme
"You see, I have a policy about honesty and ass-kicking: if you ask for it, I have to let you have it."
-Taylor Mali
"Science is the foot that kicks magic square in the nuts."
-Scratch Fury
 
Posts: 43003 | Location: Concord, NH, USA | Registered: July 20, 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
will not Ling Ling you, not ever
Member
Picture of Big Ass Panda
Posted Hide Post
lol, I was really really REALLY confused! Gosh, I'd never put him down for saying what he said. It's a very fine difference of opinion. It's two sides of the same coin really. How do you handle it best? Well you probably let the weak ended stuff go but when it gets serious, you step in.

Such as in the media, it shouldn't be tollerated in the slightest (this should be done through self regulation). However someone up on a podium? Well they should be watched closely and as soon as they say something that even boarders a suggestion that violense or some other "real" actions take place, well that should be stopped.

edit: @ Dweller

I agree with you on that one for the vast majority. Although I am currious how you would fight the indoctrination.


*********************
And I'm better built to boot!
~Ranma
 
Posts: 3803 | Location: Basking in the desert sun at the cliff's edge | Registered: February 08, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Did something right
Member
Picture of Tongster
Posted Hide Post
Again, *Shrug* I'm not seeing an overwhelming need to remove this thread. I've gotten a full spectrum of responses, from people thinking it's funny, to people agreeing, to people saying they wouldn't do it but they understand it, to people being offended. Most of the informally polled responses fall in the "wouldn't do it but understand it" area, which is about what I was aiming for. All in all, I think that's a healthy spectrum of responses for something like this, which was not meant to be warm 'n fuzzy.


----------------------------------------------------------
"It really is fun to to stick burning objects into various orifices."
"Sorry I haven't been around much, but I am easily distracted by shiny objects."
"WEIRD! WEIRDY-WEIRDO-WEIRD! WEIRDOPOTTAMUS WEIRDOSAUR! HIM! YOU! WEIRD!"-Mr. Furious
 
Posts: 11331 | Registered: February 18, 2003Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community Page 1 2 3 4 5 6